Hello and back from a business trip.
The spray on insulation is the cats meow for 2 main reasons:
1) it creates a blanket across the whole surface insulating the rafters as well. This is ideal because wood is a very poor insulator. As such , a lower R factor is required because your system is now much more efficient.
2) Because the foam is covering the whole surface it leaves no cracks or openings anywhere thus creating an air barrier. As such, you can now fill up the whole area because there is no moisture transfer.
If you can't use the foam, then I would suggest ISO board,
a highly efficient thermal insulation board composed of a rigid closed cell polyisocyanurate foam core bonded to fiber reinforced facers. It has the highest R-value of any common insulation material. It should be readily available.
We recently finished a loft above a shop with vaulted ceilings and 2x4 rafters using 2.5" ISO board tight between the rafters leaving 1" vent gap and 1" ISO board across the whole ceiling covering the rafters. THis is better than double between the rafters. You must make sure the gap can breath. This place is real cozy and easy to heat.
Hope this helps.
------------------
Bart Blainey, B.E.R.
Consultant/Journeyman Carpenter
Building Envelope Specialist
Master Renovator
provip@prodeck.org
http://www.prodeck.org
Barton Blainey (provip) specifically assumes no legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any information or process disclosed. The above further expressly advises that any use of or reliance upon the information and or opinion disclosed is at your risk .
_________________________
Bart Blainey, B.E.R.
Consultant/Journeyman Carpenter
Building Envelope Specialist
Master Renovator
provip@prodeck.org
http://www.prodeck.orgBarton Blainey (provip) specifically assumes no legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any information or process disclosed. The above further expressly advises that any use of or reliance upon the information and or opinion disclosed is at your risk .